Wednesday, 22 February 2017

Reference for All

Alice Yucht's graphic (Fullington, 2011)
(MacMeekin, 2013)



These two charts remind me of the topics discussed in Theme 2 and the many roles that the teacher-librarian’s job entitles to create the best learning environment for the students.   The main goals are to meet the students’ needs and enable them to be independent and collaborative learners.  It is important to empower the students to be critical thinkers and knowledge seekers so that they will have passion for life long learning and literacy.

The success of the library program involves having a skilled, capable, and collaborative teacher-librarian (TL) who is welcoming.  The teacher-librarian must be a good listener and decision maker to figure out the reference needs of the students.  Effective questioning during the interview process when the student has an inquiry will help the students achieve their needs. 

In order for the teacher-librarian to provide an informed and helpful answer to the student reference question, it relies on the TL knowing what is available through print and electronically in the library and beyond.  In order to have what is available in the library and on-line, the TL has to be aware of the BC curriculum and the reference needs of each grade and subject. 

Also, collaboration with the classroom teachers and through a library advisory group will ensure that the students’ reference needs are met.  By knowing what the teachers’ are focusing on currently in their classrooms as well as creating materials for learning outcome together, the TL can quickly direct the informational and reference needs of any students in the school that requires assistance.  The TL can also interview the classroom teachers, administrator, parents, students, and library advisory group about their needs for the school library program.  The more positively and effectively the teacher and TL work together the better the students will do academically according to Russell (2002).

Furthermore, the TL can use his/her knowledge about the curriculum as well as the teacher and student needs/enjoyment to purchase effective, quality, and relevant reference resources that will be “a good reference source (that) serves to answer questions, and (not) a bad reference source (that) fails to answer questions.” (Riedlling, 2013) 

(LaGarde, 2013)


The TL also needs to weed out books that are out of date, are inappropriate or have misinformation.  The above chart from LaGarde (2013) can be shared for those that are apprehensive about weeding books.

 Evaluating,Selecting, and Acquiring Learning Resources: A Guide, created by ERAC (2008) has some useful checklists that can be used to evaluate and justify the purchase of reference and other resources for the school library.  It is also a good resource for books that have been evaluated for the BC School Curriculum.
  
The role of the TL is a complex one.  The most important thing is that anyone  who has a vested interest, for improving our students' lives and education, need to work together in a meaningful way by finding the best reference resources to achieve those goals.

 References:


BC’s New Curriculum.  (2017).  Retrieved from https://curriculum.gov.bc.ca/curriculum

Evaluating, Selecting, and Acquiring Learning Resources: A Guide .  (2008).

Fullington, Fran.  (2011, February 26).  Today’s School Librarian, with thanks to
 Alice Yucht.  Retrived from

LaGarde Jennifer.  (2013, October 1).  Keeping Your Library Collection Smelling
             F.R.E.S.H! [Blog post].  Retrieved from

MacMeekin, Mia. (2013, April 12).  27 Things Your Teacher Librarian Does.

 Linworth Books.

Shayne, Russell. (2002).  Teachers and Librarians:  Collaborative Relationships.
 ERIC Digest.  Retrieved from https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED444605






Sunday, 12 February 2017

Curation of Children's Literature – Anti-bullying Books to encourage empathy, compassion, acceptance, kindness, self-awareness, and courage


Less than 2 weeks away is Pink Shirt Day on February 22nd, which is a day to stand up collectively against bullying by wearing pink after a male student was bullied in Nova Scotia for wearing pink.  Therefore, I wanted to create a curation of children’s literature books that will help focus on discussion and solutions around the topic of bullying so that no one (child or adult) will feel hopelessness, isolation, or despair.

No one should be harassed or ostracized verbally, physically, emotionally, or through social media regardless of their gender, race, religion, social economics, or appearance.  Everyone deserves to live in peace and with dignity. If we start the discussion with children at an early age about respect, inclusiveness, and acceptance then perhaps it will resonate and help themselves and others against bullying or becoming bullies.  These ideals will help them grow up to be empathetic and compassionate adults that will have the strength to stand up for what is right and help those that are wronged or in need.

The choice of books are intended to create a dialogue in the classroom so that students become aware of what bullying entails; identify the intent of a bully; and recognize the effects of bullying.   Also, the choice of literature will help the students to develop strategies, skills, and solutions to deal with bullying in a safe/healthy manner; feel empowerment to stand up for themselves and others; be proud of who they are; increase their self esteem and self worth; express their feelings about bullying; and empathize with those being bullied as well as the bully.   Indeed, the students will recognize that a little kindness goes a long way; friendship is better than fighting; and words and labels can hurt.

Since I taught elementary school and my youngest son is in Grade 4, the books that I have chosen will be focused at that grade level.  I chose a variety of books such that students can read independently, the students can read in pairs, or the teacher can read aloud.  I also tried to choose a variety of books with varying reading levels, characters, settings, genders, themes, ages, ethnic backgrounds, writing styles, illustrations, and scenario/situation.  By trying to have a diversity of books, students can perhaps find some that relate to them.  This connection with the books will provide a deeper conversation and understanding.   Also, the diverse literature will help to build knowledge, critical thinking, and literacy skills.

1.    1. Choi, Yangsook.  The Name Jar.  Dragonfly Books, 2003




This book is about a new student, Unhei, from Korea who wanted to change her name because other children on the bus had difficulty pronouncing her name and laughed about it.   But when she explained the meaning of her name at school, she was no longer teased.

This book touches on the fact that it is okay to be oneself, everyone’s name is special, and one should be proud of his/her ethnicity and heritage.  It encourages a good discussion about how making fun of someone’s name can affect his/her self-esteem. 

2. Dismondy, Maria.  Spaghetti in a Hot Dog Bun: Having the Courage To Be Who You Are.  Cardinal Rule Press, 2008   



This is a book about a girl with big beautiful head of curls who loved to enjoy her food in unconventional ways, which caused her to be mocked at school.  But in the end, she saved the bully off the playground and they become friends.

This book talks about acceptance and embracing uniqueness.  It is good to like who you are and not have to change your appearance or eating habits so that you can be like everyone else.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3cXWrUJlOK8 - Author is reading the book.

http://mariadismondy.com - Maria Dismondy's website with a list of her other books against bullying.

3. Dr. Seuss.  TheSneetches and Other Stories. Random House Books for Young Readers, 1961




This book is about these imaginary Sneetches who separated themselves as the haves and have not’s based upon the stars on their stomachs.  Instead of changing themselves constantly to be different from each other, they realized in the end that it was better to be together than divided.

This book touches on segregation and discrimination based upon appearance.  It highlights how much power a group can have over another if they think they are more superior so there is a need for equality and acceptance in order for peace.

They’re also a short cartoon video on this book that might appeal to more visual and audio learners.

4. Estes, Eleanor.  The Hundred Dresses.  Philomel Books, 2012



Wanda Petronski, a Polish girl with no friends, was from a poor neighbourhood.  She got taunted and shamed because Wanda claimed that she had a hundred dresses at her house even though she wore the same blue dress everyday to school.  In the end, her tormentors realized their mistakes and Wanda’s talent but it was too late.  Wanda and her family had moved away from small town to a larger city where there were more immigrants.

Even though this chapter book is a Newbery Honor book in 1945, it still is a great classroom discussion about the themes of bullying, racism, poverty, and exclusion that are still prevalent today.

5. Hall, Michael.  Red:  A Crayon’s Story, 2015



This book is about a blue crayon that had a red label around him.  When he couldn’t colour in red, everyone thought something was wrong with him since he didn’t match his label.  But when he started to make beautiful blue water and skies then he got accepted. 

This book discusses about not letting labels define you or affect your self worth.  It also talks about not rushing to judgment just because of a preconceived notion of a label.  What is on the inside is more important than what is on the outside.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Hh7-YpYbw8 - Author is reading the book.

6. Henkes, Kevin.  Chrysanthemum.  Greenwillow Books, 2008



Chrysanthemum, a mouse, is teased at school because her name is considered too long.  Even though initially she was confident and happy, the bullying made her feel sad and have a dislike for her name.  But with the help of a teacher that sees the beauty in her name, Chrysanthemum feels proud about her unique and original name again.  

This book is an American Library Association notable book and is another good book that talks about respecting everyone’s name and being proud of the name that one is given.  It is also good for discussion about how demeaning someone’s name can cause someone a lot of distress.


7. Ludwig, Trudy.  The Invisible Boy.  Knopf Books, 2013




The illustrations are very visual and poignant as the invisible boy, Brian, who no one seems to notice or plays with becomes more colourful as he is included in school activities when a new student arrives and wants to be his friend. 

This book shows how being ignored, excluded, and isolated can affects someone’s self esteem and self-worth.  A little bit of friendship, kindness and inclusion can go a long way.


Other anti-bullying books written by Trudy Ludwig that I like and would use are:

Ludwig, Trudy.  Just Kidding.  Tricycle Press, 2006 – This book is would be good to discuss about the difference between joking, teasing, and bullying as well as peer pressure and tattle-tailing.

Ludwig, Trudy. MySecret Bully.  Dragonfly Books, 2015 – This book talks about how friendships can change.  It also focuses on how some friends aren’t really your friends.

8.  Mobin-Uddin, Asma.  My Name is Bilal.  Boyds Mills Press, 2005



This book is about a Muslim boy named Bilal who wanted to hide his identity and change his name to Bill, after seeing his sister been bullied by boys trying to remove her hijab.  But though learning about the importance of his name and faith through a teacher, he was able to find the courage to standup against those bothering his sister and be proud of his culture. 

This book focuses on being proud of your heritage, religion, and name.  It also focuses on defending against prejudice and intolerance of cultural and religious differences.  It is more important to talk about your identity than to hide who you are.

9. Munson, Derek.  Enemy Pie.  Chronicle Books, 2000



This book is a boy who doesn’t like his new neighbour, Jeremy, because Jeremy laughed at him and didn’t invite him to his house for a play date.  Thus, the narrator put Jeremy on his enemy list and confided in his dad for help.  His dad mentioned creating a secret recipe called enemy pie but before the pie could work he had to be play nicely with his enemy for the whole day.

This is a light hearted book that discuss that if you talk to and play with your enemy, you can find out that you have more similarities than difference.  Perhaps, a new friendship can form when you spend time together and the unkindness will stop.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b_I9NgXKtC8 - Author is reading the book.


10. O’Neill, Alexis.  The Recess Queen.  Scholastic Press, 2005




This book is a rhyming book about a girl named “Mean Jean” who pushed everyone at the playground until the new girl stood up to her and became her friend.  Jean was having too much fun with her new friend to bully the other kids around.

This book encourages the students to speak up against bullying and recognize that bossiness can be bullying.  It is also a good discussion about bullying in different places and why it might occur outside of the classroom.  

11. Otoshi, Kathryn.  One. KO Kids Books, 2008



A simple yet cleverly written book about a crayon bullying other crayons until One showed up and decided to stand up against the bully by saying “no”.  The words “Everyone Counts” and “Sometimes it just takes one” are great phrases from the book.

This book focuses on the courage to stand up against bullying, which in turns encourages others to stand up together against bullying.  It also focuses on inclusion of the bully versus exclusion.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1TGaDSMAS1E  - This video is the author reading her own book and the students acting out the story.
  
12. Palacio, R.J.  Wonder.  Knopf Books, 2012



This book is about a boy named, August, who attended school for first time in Grade 5 since he had a facial difference that required many surgeries.  Most of the students except for a few were afraid to look at his face and called him names.  In the end, his classmates realized their ignorance when they witnessed August been physically harassed by strangers.

This book is a New York Time Best Seller Book and would be a good read aloud by the teacher or read by a strong reader.  This book has many different points of view of his support system as well as those that weren’t.  It is also a good book to inspire empathy, compassion, and kindness and how not to react to fear, uncomfortableness, and differences with cruelty.  It brings on a good discuss about how the students would react if someone’s physical appearance was drastically different from theirs.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hh5qbE62IyY - The author discussing her book and the reasons why she wrote it.

13. Polacco, Patricia.  Bully. Putnam’s Sons Books for Young Readers, 2012



This book is about school cliques.  It focuses on those who are in the popular group bullying verbally and through social media those that they consider less popular.  A new girl, Lyla, to the school became part of the “cool” group but she decided to standup against the bullying of her “uncool” friend and found herself being bullied as well.

This book brings up discussion about safety on the Internet and cyber bullying on social media and electronic devices.  This book also allows for a conversation around the influence of peer pressure, group mentality, and labels.

Patricia Polacco is quite a prolific writer and illustrator that has been given many awards.  Here are her thoughts on being bullied and about bullying:


14. Savageau, Cheryl. Muskrat Will Be Swimming. Cheryl Savageau. Tilbury House Publishers, 2006



This book is about a Native American girl whose classmates teased her about where she lives. Her grandfather helped her appreciate her ancestry and home by telling Seneca creation story. 

This book focuses on being proud of your heritage and your home.  It can be related to the myths and legends of First Nations as well as racial injustices.  It is a good discussion about being true to you and keeping a strong identity of self no matter what other people might say.  It also touches on social economics, turning the name calling into something that is positive, and tolerance.

15.  Sornson, Bob.  The Juice Box Bully: Empowering Kids to Stand Up for Others.  Early Learning Foundation, 2010



This book is about a new student, Pete, who started to bully other students so that he wouldn’t be bullied as in his previous school.  The students took a pledge and stood up for Pete despite his mean actions and words.

This book focuses on not being a bystander and to speak up.  It also discusses standing up for each other or asking an adult for help when someone (including bully) is being bullied.  It looks into why a bully might be unkind and having empathy for him or her.  Also, the pledge that is used in this book can be used for other classrooms or the classes can write their own pledges.

16. Woodson, Jacqueline.  Each Kindness.  Penguin Young Readers Book, 2012



This book is about a girl named Maya who no one wanted to play with.  But by the time the bullies realized the teacher’s message of kindness is always better, Maya had already moved to another school.

This book talks about lost opportunity and that to be kind is so much better than been mean.  There can be classroom discussions around the fact that kindness opens the doors to more opportunities and friendships.  This book is also a winner of the Coretta Scott King Honor and Jane Addams Peace Award.

References:

Choi, Yangsook.  The Name Jar.  Dragonfly Books, 2003

Dismondy, Maria.  Spaghetti in a Hot Dog Bun: Having the Courage To Be Who You Are.  Cardinal Rule Press, 2008            
           
Dr. Seuss.  The Snitches and Other StoriesRandom House Books for Young Readers, 1961

Estes, Eleanor.  The Hundred Dresses.  Philomel Books, 2012

Hall, Michael.  Red:  A Crayon’s Story, 2015

Henkes, Kevin.  Chrysanthemum.  Greenwillow Books, 2008

Ludwig, Trudy.  Just Kidding.  Tricycle Press, 2006 

Ludwig, Trudy. My Secret Bully.  Dragonfly Books, 2015 

Ludwig, Trudy.  The Invisible Boy.  Knopf Books, 2013

Mobin-Uddin, Asma.  My Name is Bilal.  Boyds Mills Press, 2005

Munson, Derek.  Enemy Pie.  Chronicle Books, 2000

O’Neill, Alexis.  The Recess Queen.  Scholastic Press, 2005

Otoshi, Kathryn.  One. KO Kids Books, 2008

Palacio, R.J.  Wonder.  Knopf Books, 2012

Polacco, Patricia.  Bully. Putnam’s Sons Books for Young Readers, 2012

Savageau, Cheryl. Muskrat Will Be Swimming. Cheryl Savageau. Tilbury House Publishers, 2006

Sornson, Bob.  The Juice Box Bully:  Empowering Kids to Stand Up for Others.  Early Learning Foundation, 2010

Woodson, Jacqueline.  Each Kindness.  Penguin Young Readers Book, 2012

http://mariadismondy.com











Friday, 3 February 2017

World Book Encyclopedia - To Buy or Not to Buy?

Assignment 1:  Evaluation and Selection of a Reference Resource

Part 1

The printed reference section of the school library is only one small bookcase of reference books.  On one of the shelves, the World Book encyclopedia is alphabetically organized in 22 volumes with a Research Guide Index.  The bindings on the encyclopedia are welcoming and appealing since they create a complete picture of a diversity of smiling faces. 

2004 World Book Encyclopedia

Since the World Book encyclopedia is from 2004, some of the topics are no longer relevant or current.  They are missing recent information and technology that have occurred in the past 13 years.  According to Riedling et al, any reference resource that is more than 5 years old is out-of-date and needs to be replaced.   There are many updates that need to be done and additional topics that need to be added to these existing World Book especially in terms of politics, technology, inventions, scientific discoveries, and current events.

Some of the illustrations, content, and layout are still quite interesting and beautiful. The writing is quite concise and informative as well as crosses different curriculum areas. There is quite a wealth of topics and everything is alphabetized making it easier to look for a particular topic.  The detailed diagrams, stunning pictures, and graphic organizers are helpful to English language learners as well as all learners.

Rubric for Evaluation and Selection of a Reference Resource
(Based on Ann Riedling et al, Reference skills for the school librarian:Tools and Tipspages 17 to 25; and Aaron Mueller, instructor, for UBC LIBE 467 course) 


Aspect
Not Very Useful
Useful
Very Useful
Relevancy
Information is not relevant, inaccurate, homogeneous, not comprehensive, poorly written, not laid out well, and dated
Information is somewhat relevant, accurate, comprehensive, heterogeneous, well written, laid out well and relatively current
Information is relevant, accurate, diverse, immaculately written, well laid out with diagrams, illustrations or pictures, and current
Purpose
Not very informative, nor insightful, uninteresting, difficult, biased, and not a very good starting point for inquiry based questions
Somewhat informative, insightful, interesting, understandable, objective, and a good starting point for inquiry based questions
Very informative, insightful, engaging, understandable, objective, and a great starting point for inquiry based questions
Currency
6 years or more
5 years or less
Less than 1 year
Curricular Connections
Limited or no connection to grade levels and British Columbia’s (BC’s) New Curriculum as well as not across the curriculum
Some connection to the different grade levels and BC’s New Curriculum as well as across most of the curriculum
Meets most or all of the grade levels and curricular areas in BC’s New Curriculum as well as across  the curriculum
Library Space Efficiency & Usage
Takes up a lot of shelf space with limited usage and difficult access
Doesn’t take up too much self space with some usage and access
Shelf space is adequate for the high amount of usage and quick access



Part 2

Since the school library is part of the Vancouver School Board District (VSB), the online World Book encyclopedia is available readily through Webcat (The VSB Online Library Catalogue).   The online World Book is quite comprehensive, up-to-date, informative, and caters to the different grade levels, personal and curricular interest, and different reading levels.  Thus, students, teachers, parents, and administrators have easy access to the electronic reference so the focus will only be on whether or not to purchase a new set of printed World Book encyclopedia as a reference resource for the school library.

Online World Book from Webcat

The criteria to purchase the printed 2017 World Book must meet the “Very Useful” part of the Rubric created in Part 1 and having the budget available as these encyclopedias are very expensive and priced at USD$ 1,199.95 (approximately CAD$1,558.14). 


Printed World Book Encyclopedia


To begin with, the World Book encyclopedia has been around for 100 years since it was first published in 1917 so it shows their usefulness as shown by its longevity.  Also, according to their website, they have “more than 4,000 scholars and experts as contributors, reviewers, and consultants” that write their topics.  After each topic, the writers are listed with their credentials as well as references for further knowledge exploration so that helps with purpose and relevance on the Rubric.  

Also, the 2017 World Book mentions that it has “over 1,000 new or revised articles and over 25,000 photographs, maps, and illustrations” as well as references to new videos.  It is yearly reviewed by experts and fact checkers which again adds to the relevancy, purpose, and currency of the Rubric.  There has been an astonishing amount of articles, photographs, maps, and illustrations updated and added over the past 13 years compared to school library’s 2004 World Book.

Moreover, the World Book is American based and published in Chicago, Illinois so there is a need to evaluate their curricular connection with BC’s new curriculum. Their centennial binding covers create the Sierra Nevada Mountain Range with their giant sequoia trees and Lake Tahoe that borders both Nevada and California.  The 2017 new highlights section mentions famous Americans, 2016 United States presidential election, and the California Gold Rush.  Before it can be purchased, there has to be an assurance that there are sufficient and useful amounts of Canadian content for Canadian students.  Therefore, I used the World Book on-line and 2004 World Book to check its current and past Canadian content.   Most of the Canadian contents that I looked up were available and contained articles such as the First Nations, first prime Minister of Canada (Sir John A. MacDonald), current Prime Minister (Justin Trudeau as well as his father, Pierre), Fur Trade, Canadian history, Terry Fox, the provinces, the territories, and landforms in Canada.  One search that could not be found was Pink Shirt Day against bullying but overall, the new encyclopedia would meet the curricular connections of the Rubric.

Furthermore, the Rubric's library space, efficiency, and usage will all be met with the new World Book purchase.  The 2004 World Book encyclopedia looks quite well used.  Some of the pages are crinkled and Book #2 is missing.  The spines on some of the books are warped.  A new set would replace the old set on the shelf and be better labelled and advertised with the signage “A Great Reference to Begin your Inquiry.”   The new set would also be moved to the top shelf of the bookcase for easier access and visibility.  The printed World Book encyclopedia is a great starting point for learning; is easily accessible and formatted; doesn’t require the Internet and electronic devices to look up information; and helps to provide background knowledge and further references to answer their questions.  It gives the students a reliable and tactile source without having to shift through the mountains of information found on the Internet, which can be overwhelming due to the need to evaluate the information critically for validity and accuracy.  Also, my children, children’s teachers, husband and public librarian friend, all, like World Book and see the encyclopedia as a very useful reference resource.

In conclusion, there is still value presently in replacing the older 2004 World Book by purchasing the newest printed World Book 2017 (100th Anniversary addition) as it fulfills the “Very Useful” part of the Rubik.  



https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KTfppngPqOs -Video from Youtube about 2012 World Book


References:

https://curriculum.gov.bc.ca/curriculum

Mueller, Aaron, instructor, 2016W-LIBE467-63C-Information Services I course, University of British Columbia, 2017.